Difference Between GEICO Home Insurance and Allstate Insurance

Edited by Diffzy | Updated on: April 30, 2023


Difference Between GEICO Home Insurance and Allstate Insurance

Why read @ Diffzy

Our articles are well-researched

We make unbiased comparisons

Our content is free to access

We are a one-stop platform for finding differences and comparisons

We compare similar terms in both tabular forms as well as in points


Insurance is used by both households and businesses to protect themselves from the financial effects of a single catastrophe. Insurance premiums are paid regularly by most homes and organizations. Premiums are determined by the probability of certain events occurring among a group of people. This fund compensates members of the group who have a specific unpleasant experience. Many people have a variety of insurance policies, including health insurance, which pays for medical care; car insurance, which pays if they are the driver in an automobile accident; home or renter's insurance, which pays if their belongings are stolen or damaged by fire; and life insurance, which pays for the principal's family if he or she dies. Insurance coverage can be characterized as a contract in the form of a financial protection policy. This insurance protects a person's finances in the event of a disaster. The insured is the policyholder, while the insurer is the insurance-providing company/insurance carrier/underwriter. In many cases, insurers give policyholders cash coverage or payment. In exchange for insurance coverage, the policyholder pays an amount to the insurance company known as a "premium." The insurance guarantees to compensate the insured for their losses, but only under certain circumstances. The quantity of insurance coverage or 'policy limit' is determined by the amount of premium paid. A legal agreement between two parties, the insurer and the insured, is known as insurance. Insurance coverage or insurance policy is another term for it. The insurance covers the insured against financial losses that may arise in specific conditions. Insurance is a contract in which one party, the insurance company or insurer, agrees to repay another, the insured, for a certain loss or harm in exchange for a predetermined sum known as a premium.

Insurance Coverage Features

  1. The use of an insurance policy as a hedge against an uncertain loss is a type of risk management strategy.
  2. Insurance coverage does not compensate for the severity of a loss. It just ensures that the loss is shared and divided across a large number of people.
  3. An insurance company’s various clients share their risks. As a result, they split the premiums. As a result, when one or a few people suffer a financial loss, the money is paid out of this collected fund. As a result, every client must pay a little cost.
  4. Medical expenses, car damage, and property loss/damage can all be covered depending on the type of insurance.
  5. The premium, policy limit, and deductible are the three essential components of an insurance coverage policy. When obtaining insurance coverage, the customer should check it attentively.

Difference Between Allstate and Geico Insurance Company in Tabular Form

Parameters Of Comparison Allstate Insurance Geico  Insurance
Settled In 1931, Allstate Insurance Company was established. Northbrook, Illinois, is now the company's headquarters. The Geico Corporation was founded in 1936. The company's headquarters are in Washington, DC.
Financial Ratings Allstate has an AM Best rating of (A+) and a BBB rating of (A-). As a result, overall financial and customer satisfaction ratings are low. Geico has an AM Best rating of (A++) and a BBB rating of (B+). As a result, both the financial and customer satisfaction ratings are excellent.
Coverage Options Personal injury protection (PIP), medical coverage, motorist coverage, personal liability, theft restoration, property, and scheduled coverage are some of the types of coverage available. Personal injury protection (PIP), roadside assistance coverage, personal liability, theft restoration, and replacement cost in the event of property valuation are all included in the policy.
Online Capabilities The Allstate app does not offer outstanding online services. Customer satisfaction with Allstate's app is 2.4 out of 5. Their most popular features, however, are QuickFoto and Drive wise. The Geico app is the most popular, with several customer ratings of 4.8 out of 5. You can check your coverage, pay bills, and more using the online portal.
Pricing  The cost of Allstate vehicle insurance is exorbitant. However, this is not the case for DUI drivers. Geico vehicle insurance is less expensive. As a result, they are economical and handy for drivers between the ages of 18 and 70.

What is Geico Insurance Company?

Few people had the wisdom and fortitude to establish a new business in the mid-1930s, during the height of the Great Depression. Leo and Lillian Goodwin, a husband-and-wife combination, were up to the challenge. During his early career in Texas, Leo Goodwin scribbled a business plan, certain that he could build a successful auto insurance business by selling directly to defined consumer groups. He put his concept into action in 1936, establishing the Government Employees Insurance Company (GEICO), which is still well-known and well-loved today. Few people realize that GEICO was designed specifically for government employees and enlisted military officers. GEICO is a private American automotive insurance company with headquarters in Chevy Chase, Maryland. After State Farm, it is the second-largest automotive insurer in the United States. As of 2017, GEICO was a Berkshire Hathaway wholly-owned company, insuring over 24 million cars for over 15 million policyholders. GEICO insures individual passenger automobiles in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. The company's website and GEICO Field Representatives, qualified insurance brokers who sell directly to clients over the phone, are used to spread coverage. The company's mascot is Jake Wood, an English actor who portrays a gold dust day gecko with a Cockney accent.

Despite the use of the term "government" in its name, GEICO has always been a private company associated with any US government organization. Leo Goodwin Sr. and his wife Lillian Goodwin founded the company in 1936 to sell motor insurance to federal government employees. Property and umbrella insurance are also sold by GEICO; however, the risk is passed on to third-party companies. The policies are managed by GEICO as the "insurance agent," with a separate customer care staff handling the property and umbrella policies. Customers usually deal with GEICO directly over the phone and online, however, the local agent network comprises over 300 independent locations across the country. GEICO is currently the second-largest private vehicle insurance provider in the United States.

In 2015, GEICO began selling coverage for rideshare drivers in a select high-population state, including Texas, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Georgia. Insurance experts have complimented GEICO's business-coverage, which has quickly placed the company as the largest insurer for ridesharing company drivers. GEICO commercials have featured several well-known mascots. Who knows if the company's founders, Leo and Lillian Goodwin, could have predicted the company's incredible success? Could they have foreseen that in Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Florida, Hawaii, Maryland, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, and Virginia, GEICO would become the most popular vehicle insurance provider? Would they have guessed that the company would grow to over 40,000 employees in 17 major locations around the country, with insurance coverage in all 50 states and the District of Columbia? Was it possible for them to foretell what would happen in the next GEICO chapter? Maybe so, but one thing hasn't changed about GEICO since 1936: the company's future appears bright. Whatever GEICO's future holds, the company's essential values will not alter.

What is Allstate Insurance Company?

According to consumer studies, the insurance business has a long way to go before totally satisfying clients. Customers want insurance to be more friendly and simple; they want the claims procedure to be fairer and more efficient, and they want their agents to be trustworthy and knowledgeable about their needs.

The parent company of Allstate Insurance Company, the country's second-largest property and casualty insurer by premiums, is the Allstate Corporation. In terms of home and car insurance market share in the United States, Allstate is second only to State Farm Insurance Companies. Through its Business Insurance branch, Allstate Life Insurance Company offers life, annuity, and pension policies, as well as numerous coverages for small and medium-sized businesses. Allstate's 20 million customers are served by 15,200 full-time "captive" agents and thousands of independent agents in the United States and Canada. Personal property and liability products account for about three-quarters of Allstate's revenue, with Life Operations accounting for 15%. The Allstate Corporation is the parent corporation of Allstate Insurance Company, the country's second-largest property and casualty insurer by premiums. Allstate Insurance Companies is second only to State Farm Insurance Companies in terms of home and auto insurance market share in the United States. Allstate Life Insurance Company's Business Insurance division provides small and medium-sized enterprises with life, annuity, and pension policies, as well as a variety of other coverage. In the United States and Canada, 15,200 full-time "captive" agents and thousands of independent agents serve Allstate's 20 million consumers. About three-quarters of Allstate's revenue comes from personal property and liability products, with Life Operations accounting for 15%. Allstate built its first permanent sales office in a Chicago Sears store in 1934, signaling the start of a shift away from direct mail and toward agents as the primary sales channel. Even with the extra expenditure of agent commissions, the corporation was able to keep costs under control by using Sears’s stores. Throughout the rest of the Great Depression, Allstate grew slowly yet steadily. The company's premium volume had grown to $1.8 million by 1936. By 1941, premium revenue had more than tripled, reaching $6.8 million from over 189,000 active policies. James Barker was appointed chairman of Allstate's board of directors in 1943.

"With Allstate, you're in good hands." According to Davis W. Ellis, the company's global sales manager, the now-famous tagline initially appeared in 1950. Allstate’s success in the 1950s prepared the way for further success in the following decades. The company expanded not only its sales volume but also its product range and operating space. After only six years of operation, the Allstate Life Insurance subsidiary surpassed the $1 billion mark in insurance in force in 1963. Over 5,000 brokers were selling Allstate life, auto, home, and business insurance at the time. The next year, Allstate Insurance Company of Canada and Allstate Life Insurance Company of Canada were established as new subsidiaries. In Menlo Park, California, the Judson B. Branch Research Center (later called the Allstate Research and Planning Center) opened in 1966 A year later; the company’s headquarters were moved to a new 723,000-square-foot complex in Northbrook, Illinois, a Chicago suburb. Meanwhile, Allstate continued to diversify its insurance portfolio throughout the decade, adding worker's compensation insurance in 1964, surety bonds in 1966, ocean marine coverage in 1967, and a business package policy in 1969. There were 6,500 Allstate Insurance agents in 1970. Allstate launched a mutual fund that year. By acquiring National First Corporation in 1972, Allstate joined the mortgage banking market. The company bought PMI Mortgage Insurance Company the next year, marking its first foray into the market. Allstate insurance became provided through independent agents in rural areas not served by company-employed agents about the same period. Allstate earned $203 million in 1973, accounting for over 30% of parent firm Sears' total.

Difference Between Geico Insurance and Allstate Insurance In Points

  1. GEICO is less expensive for the ordinary motorist, as well as individuals with bad credit and those who have been in an accident or received a traffic ticket. In addition, GEICO has a higher J.D. In 43 of the 50 states, Power Score is the less expensive choice.
  2. Allstate is less expensive for students and anyone who has been charged with DUI. Allstate also has a lower number of customer complaints.
  3. GEICO auto insurance is ideal for drivers who like to manage their coverage as well as those with minor traffic violations.
  4. Allstate auto insurance is ideal for drivers, who like to deal directly with an agent, as well as young drivers and those with a DUI on their record.
  5. When it comes to cost, GEICO is usually less expensive than Allstate. GEICO's average annual premium is $1,047. This is $304 less than Allstate's average annual premium of $1,351.


Allstate and Geico are two good options for homeowners looking for coverage for their house, personal property, and liabilities. However, each of these companies will offer slightly different coverage options, endorsements, and savings. This Old House Reviews compiled this Allstate vs. Geico home insurance comparison to assist you in understanding the differences and selecting the best homeowners insurance for your home. Homeowner’s insurance policies cover the dwelling, other structures, personal goods, additional living expenses, personal liabilities, and medical payments to others. Examine the coverage options and endorsements offered by each firm. We collected quotations for a one-story home with 3.5 baths and four bedrooms to give you an idea of what Allstate or Geico coverage may cost. Geico has fewer coverage options, endorsements, and savings than Allstate. You can choose personal property coverage for 60 to 75 percent of your house instead of Geico's standard 70 percent. Allstate has more deductible, discount, and endorsement options than Geico, which adds one liability coverage option and two medical payment options. Allstate's quote was significantly more than the national average while receiving quotations; however, this could be due to the location. In Texas, for example, hurricanes are common, making the home more difficult to insure and raising the rate. In terms of customer service, both Geico and Allstate offer 24-hour customer assistance, customer portals, mobile apps, and BBB A+ ratings (BBB). Keep in mind that Geico obtains its policies from underwriting businesses, which means that if you need to file a claim or have a policy question, you may need to contact the underwriting company directly through their customer care channels.


  1.  "Fortune 500 Companies 2018: Who Made the List". Fortune. Retrieved November 10, 2018.
  2.  "Allstate to Pay $1.4 Billion for Square Trade, Seller of Warranties for Mobile Devices, Appliances"Insurance Journal. November 29, 2016. Retrieved July 25, 2019.
  3.  Castronuovo, Celine (April 20, 2021). "Geico customers' driver's license numbers exposed in breach". The Hill. Retrieved April 21, 2021.
  4.  Aayush Majumdar. "CONFIRMED: Germain Racing to Sell Team and Leave NASCAR With No Sponsorship for 2021 Season". EssentiallySports. Retrieved December 26, 2021.


Cite this article

Use the citation below to add this article to your bibliography:



MLA Style Citation

"Difference Between GEICO Home Insurance and Allstate Insurance." Diffzy.com, 2024. Thu. 29 Feb. 2024. <https://www.diffzy.com/article/difference-between-geico-home-insurance-and-allstate-483>.

Edited by

Share this article